Cash Advances Explained: How Different Products Work and What You May Pay
When used as a term, Cash Advance describes many different ways to get money before you have it. This can include Payday Loans, cash withdrawals made against a credit card, or the advance of wages earned but not received. Because each of these describes a different method of getting money, there are varying costs associated with each of these methods.
Before agreeing to an advance of any kind, you need to find out what you are signing up for, calculate how much you will have to pay back, and when the payment will be made. Because the payment may be due in only a few days, it can be extremely expensive to borrow a small amount of money.
Key takeaways
- Being called a Cash Advance is a broad term that describes a payday loan, advance of wages, or use of a credit card. The description of the agreement explains the cash advance.
- It is extremely important to understand the cost of a cash advance. Compare the APR and interest rates, fees, total advance amount, and the date by which it must be repaid.
- It is extremely important to understand the date on which the advance must be repaid. If the advance is repaid through an automatic debit or payroll deduction, it can lead to insufficient funds if it leaves you without enough to cover your obligations such as food, shelter, and other expenses.
- Using a cash advance may mean you incur a cost. Advances can become expensive if they are repeated.
- Explore alternatives when you need to take out a cash advance. Options such as payment plans, employer assistance, and a bank or credit union may save you money while still meeting your objective.
What can “cash advance” mean?
A cash advance should not be exclusively analyzed through its definition. The following three products will help us better understand what cash advance means in the context of each.
| Product | Where the money comes from | How repayment usually works | Costs to check |
| Payday or single-payment cash advance loan | A lender offers a cash advance through the provision of a small loan. | The loan balance and the finance charge are typically due together on or around the next payday, though the loan structure and state rules may vary. | The finance charge, APR, late payment and returned payment fees, and any renewal fees (if permitted). |
| Credit card cash advance | This is where a cash advance is drawn against the credit limit on the card, usually at an ATM or other financial institution. | The cash advance amount is subject to the terms of the credit card agreement, and interest accrues on the cash advance amount. | Cash advance fee and APR, the date the interest begins, and an ATM fee. |
| Paycheck or salary advance | This is the advance of funds related to wages that have already been earned or will be earned in the future. | The advance amount may be recovered through payroll or an associated bank account. | Subscription fees, service fees, requested tips, account fees, and the cost associated with repeated use. |
There are other products that may use “cash advance” in their marketing. Be sure to examine the contract and disclosures to confirm who is the money provider, if the transaction is a credit transaction, how the cost is determined, and what, if any, authorization the money provider has to collect payment.
How payday-style cash advances work
A payday cash advance loan is generally a small, high-cost loan due on the borrower’s next payday or within a short period. Repayment may be arranged through an electronic debit, a post-dated check, or another method described in the agreement. Payday lending and loan amounts vary by state. Some states outlaw the practice altogether; others allow payday lending but limit the amounts and/or fees or methods of loan repayment.
A common example provided by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is that a $15 charge for every $100 borrowed equates to a $345 repayment on a $300 two-week loan; this works out to an estimated APR of almost 400%. Again, this is an example and the fees charged by lenders will vary. The lender, structure of the loan, and applicable laws will contribute to the fees charged. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau also provides examples explaining that if rollover is permitted, fees can be charged without reducing the balance.
The Annual Percentage Rate (APR) of a loan is helpful for determining the cost of credit, but the dollar amount also matters to the household budget. A complete cost of credit review includes the amount received, finance charge, total repayment, date due, and any fees that may apply after a late or unsuccessful payment.
How credit-card cash advances work
A credit card cash advance does not generate a payday loan like payday cash advance loans do. Issuers may charge a fee that is either a flat dollar value or a percentage of the requested amount. The ATM operator may charge a fee as well.
Cash advances often have a separate APR from purchases, and interest accrues from the date of the transaction. Fees associated with cash advance transactions are also usually outlined in the credit card agreement and monthly statement. The CFPB advises that cash withdrawals should be done with caution.
Estimate the cost of a card advance by determining how long it’ll take you to pay it off. Making only the minimum payment may leave an outstanding balance and cause more interest to accrue.
How paycheck and earned-wage advances work
Paycheck advance services, offered by some employers and directly by some apps, allow employees to access a portion of their earnings prior to payday. These products come with a variety of terms and may include fees.
Consider how much a series of small fees will add up to. Review the costs associated with each transaction and the total cost after a series of transactions. Think about how much money will be taken out of your next paycheck as well as whether your account will be debited.
The regulatory framework of these products varies. For a borrowing decision, the important questions remain the same: what funds arrive, what fees are charged, when will the funds be paid back, and what will happen if the account lacks enough money.
How to compare an advance before accepting it
- Identifying the product. Payday loan, card-linked, wage-linked, installment loan, or something else?
- Note the advance amount. Is there a fee that is deducted before processing the advance to you?
- Add every required cost. These include, but are not limited to, interest, finance charges, subscription charges, transfer charges, and processing charges. Consider a “tip” as a cost if you expect to give it.
- What is the amount due for repayment and on what date? For an installment loan, what is the total amount of repayments due and the repayment schedule?
- How will the provider collect the amount due? What authorization does the provider have to withdraw the amount due? Will it be an ACH debit, bank card payment, or post-dated check? What is the procedure if the collection is an error?
- Will the advance be affordable? Will repaying the advance leave you financially strained? Can you pay the amount due and still provide for basic necessities for yourself or your family?
- Failure to pay terms. What are the collection fees, returned check fees, costs of overdrafts, and the risk of collections? What are the provisions for extending the loan?
Main risks to consider
- A new cash shortfall: a single large payment or withdrawal can lead to a cash shortfall for basic expenses.
- Repeat borrowing: Taking another advance to cover the gap created by the first advance can lead to a continuous expense from an advance.
- Bank account costs: An attempted withdrawal may lead to an overdraft fee or a nonsufficient-funds fee on your account.
- Costly extensions: Where renewals or rollovers are allowed, paying another fee may extend the due date without reducing the original principal.
- Data and authorization issues: Be aware that applications may request identity, income, payroll and/or bank information. Check the company to ensure you understand how they may use and share this information.
Payday lending laws vary. Take care to determine the relevant state laws and consult the appropriate regulator and/or attorney general before considering a payday-style product. A guide to state payday loan laws can be found online.
Alternatives that may cost less
The best alternatives will depend on the reason for the request, how urgent the request is, and the ability of the family to make another payment.
- Buy more time! While this may not be possible for all creditors, contacting your utility, landlord, or doctor’s office may result in a due date change or payment plan at no cost, or for a small fee, to you. Compare any fee with the total cost of a loan.
- Check with your employer and the community. Resources such as payroll advances, hardship funds, nonprofit assistance, and local benefit programs may help with your expense.
- Check with the bank or credit union to see whether it offers small-dollar options.
- Review personal loans. While some may provide longer time to repay, approval and pricing vary. Review the disclosures for interest, fees, repayment terms, and total cost rather than assuming an offer is affordable.
- Less costly alternatives to borrowing. Consider negotiating charges, delaying a non-essential expense, or returning a purchase.
Longer repayment terms may lower each payment due, but total interest may be higher. When considering the full cost of the loan, do not sacrifice other necessities.
Protect your information and watch for scams
Hold your information safe and don’t fall victim to scams. Don’t share your Social Security number, banking info, or access to your payroll until you confirm the company, know the reason for the request and the reason they need access, and you have read the company’s privacy policy and their information sharing policy. Use the company’s website or a regulator’s license lookup. Do not use links sent in an unsolicited email.
- Do not pay anyone who guarantees a loan or line of credit in exchange for an upfront fee.
- Remain cautious of requests to move quickly on a transaction and pay by a method that is difficult to undo (i.e., wire transfer, gift card, crypto). Be cautious about requests to pay before obtaining a loan.
- Make sure the connection is secure, but remember that seeing a padlock in your browser does not prove the website is legitimate.
- Keep a copy of everything, including agreements, disclosures, payment authorization forms, and messages.
The FTC advises you to be wary of someone who guarantees a loan or credit but requires an upfront fee. Its resource on advance-fee loans outlines examples of these scams and how to submit a complaint.
Frequently asked questions
Is a cash advance the same as a payday loan?
Not always. Payday loans are sometimes called cash advance loans, but a cash advance can also refer to money drawn from a credit card or accessed through a paycheck-advance product. The agreement dictates how the product works.
Why can a small fee produce a high APR?
APR (annual percentage rate) expresses a borrowing cost as a yearly rate. For example, a loan that is repaid quickly may charge a small fee. If annualized, that small fee can produce a high APR. Keep an eye on both APR and the dollar amount you’ll actually have to pay.
Does “no interest” mean an advance is free?
Not necessarily. These products may have other costs, including a subscription, delivery, or transaction fee. Be aware of all the costs associated with a service and whether you think you may use the service frequently.
What if I cannot repay on time?
Contact the company before the payment is due to see if there are any options and to see how much that option will cost. Do not automatically assume that payment extensions exist. Review the payment authorization and the balance in your account so that it does not go too low and incur an unnecessary bank fee.
Bottom line
The label for a cash advance does not reveal its cost, and covering all the costs for a loan is important. Figure out the date of collection and see if there’s enough left after paying that loan back. If the loan would leave you with no money, reconsider if this is the best option. Consider other options that may be lower cost or no loan at all.
